Fantasy Football Rookie Rankings: Players You’ll Brag About All Season

The right rookie can be a real late-season dark horse, turning things around at the last minute while everyone else’s so-called ‘sleeper picks’ underperform time and again. 

With our list of fantasy football rookies in 2025, it’s your turn to find those real hidden gems and draft a team worth bragging about. 

Looking for more tips about everything football? Check out the Giant Sports Cards blog.

Rookies You Can’t Miss Out On

Kyle Monangai

Kyle Monangai is a running back for the Chicago Bears, and when it comes to fantasy football rookie rankings, he tends to fly under the radar quite a bit. Some of the skepticism is warranted, considering many believe Swift to be a much stronger player.

That said, Monangai is excellent at breaking tackles and has some solid heft behind his plays. If you’re looking for a late-round rookie, he’s a solid choice for your draft.

Tyler Warren

Despite being the 14th pick for the Colts, Warren has had one of the most impactful rookie seasons we’ve seen in a while, earning him a core spot on the team’s defense. 

What gives him such a high spot in our fantasy football rookie rankings? He’s fast, he can block with the best of them, and his receiving prowess speaks for itself. You might see his cards from football hobby boxes pick up value real soon, as well.

Kaleb Johnson

Kaleb Johnson had something of a shaky start as an RB for the Steelers, but he remains one of the top fantasy football rookies in 2025. He’s managed to climb back from an injury, and he’s a solid candidate to put in the points later this season, which makes him a great late RB pick if you’re not sold on Monangai. 

TreVeyon Henderson

As far as our fantasy football rookie rankings are concerned, TreVeyon Henderson shows immense potential for early adopters. He’s been a part of most offensive snaps for the Patriots so far, and Rhamondre Stevenson being sidelined gives Henderson a wonderful opportunity to shine.

What else makes the Patriots’ RB worth watching? He’s a consistent dual threat that catches as well as he contributes to pass protection, and his speed puts him in a unique position to earn points. 

If he can keep himself free of injuries, you might just see him on an exclusive Topps sports card next year!

Tetairoa McMillan

Some of the best picks in fantasy football rookie rankings aren’t breakout stars who deliver point-heavy early games. They’re consistent players who contribute throughout the season. 

That’s why experts are so bullish on this wide receiver for the Carolina Panthers. He’s currently leading the team in receptions and is one of the handful of Panthers players with two TD grabs. 

Get The Best Fantasy Football Rookies of 2025

Building an epic FF team online is great, but seeing it in real life in all its parallel glory? Unbeatable. Be the first to unbox upcoming sports card releases and save more with our competitive prices and free shipping on US orders over $199. 

Order now at Giant Sports Cards and Unbox Your Love Of The Game™ with the ultimate sports card store.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most accurate fantasy football rookie ranking website?

There’s no single best answer here. Every website follows its own methodology for determining the most promising rookies, and you’ll see varying rankings for players across the board.

Are football rookie cards valuable?

Absolutely, especially if they’re in-demand players that are common fantasy football picks! Demand is directly related to the value of a sports card.

What are the most promising rookies in football right now? 

Players like TreVeyon Henderson, Tyler Warren, and Tetairoa McMillan are worth keeping an eye on right now. These rookies show immense promise and could be all-time greats.