Which MLB Draft Positions Actually Produce Stars? A 40-Year MLB Draft Outcome Analysis
In This Article
|
Every June, a team’s fanbase convinces itself that this year’s first round pick is the next Ken Griffey Jr. Most of the time, they’re wrong. Not because scouts are bad at their jobs, but because the math of the draft is stacked against almost everyone who gets picked, no matter where.
We pulled together outcome data spanning decades of the draft to answer questions about MLB draft pick success over time. How often do MLB draft picks become stars, and how much does draft slot matter once a player is actually on the field? Get the answers you need with this sports card blog.
What Counts as a ‘Star’?
For the purposes of this MLB draft analysis, it’s worth outlining what we actually mean by ‘star’ when discussing which MLB draft picks produce the most stars. Different studies measure this differently, so rather than forcing everything into one definition, we’ll use three lenses:
- Reaching the majors at all (baseline)
- Producing real value (career WAR)
- Becoming a genuine star (All-Star appearances, Hall of Fame case, etc.)
Most Picks Never Make the Majors
Draft Classes, 1965-2004
Across all draft picks through 2004, 85.86% never appeared in an MLB game, and only 3% produced more than 5 Wins Above Replacement (WAR) during their years of team control.
Signed Draftees, 1981-2010
According to our MLB draft analysis, from 1981 to 2010, only 17.6% of the best MLB draft picks who were signed eventually made it to the majors. That rate also varies dramatically depending on where a player is drafted.
Only 9.8% of signed draftees have managed to register even 0.1 career WAR, which is roughly 83 players per draft class.
Round Matters (and The Drop-Off)
The Round-by-Round Cliff
MLB draft success is likeliest for first-round picks based on our MLB draft analysis. First-round picks from 1981-2010 reached the majors at a 73% rate, and in the 2004 draft specifically, only two of 29 signed first-rounders failed to make the majors. That’s a 93% success rate.
|
Round |
Reached the Majors |
|
Round 1 |
73% |
|
Round 2 |
51% |
|
Round 3 |
40% |
First-Round Picks Outproduce Everyone Else
A peer-reviewed study from 2022 tracking over 1,600 players drafted between 2005 and 2015 found that first-round draftees had a higher average career WAR than players drafted in rounds 2 through 20, and that the first five picks collectively had higher WAR than picks grouped 16 through 30.
The No.1 Overall Pick: A Cautionary Tale?
Our MLB draft analysis of the best MLB draft picks reveals that no first overall pick was inducted into the Hall of Fame until 2016, when Ken Griffey Jr. was elected with a record 99.3% of the vote. He’s since been joined by only three other top picks:
- Chipper Jones in 2018
- Harold Baines in 2019
- Joe Mauer in 2024
And that’s across 60 drafts through 2024. This stat about MLB draft pick success over time is part of why a Topps sports card from a strong class can be worth chasing even when it wasn’t the headline pick.
When The Wrong Player Goes First
A cursory MLB draft analysis reveals that being the first pick is no guarantee of success. In the 1966 draft, the Mets took catcher Steve Chilcott first overall. He dislocated his shoulder in the minors sliding into a base and cemented his legacy as one of baseball’s biggest busts. The second pick that year, Reggie Jackson, went on to a Hall of Fame career.
Where The Real Value Hides
Stars Scattered Past Pick 15
Among more than 600 first-round picks since 2010, 18 players have been worth at least 30 career WAR, and of those 18, seven were taken 15th overall or later. MLB draft success in late picks is absolutely possible, and more common than you might think based on our MLB draft analysis.
If you’re picking up Bowman sports cards, never count the late picks out. Your rookie could double in value in a few years.
What This Means For You
If you’re interested in finding the best MLB draft picks for your baseball card collection, these stats are worth paying attention to. A first-round pick is still the single best predictor available at draft time, but stars can come from mid-to-late rounders as well.
Whether you’re chasing a Panini baseball box or the most exciting upcoming sports card releases, our legendary rewards program and free shipping on orders over $199 make it all effortless. Unbox Your Love Of The Game™ with Giant Sports Cards, the ultimate sports card store.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can MLB draft analysis help me find valuable sports cards?
Absolutely! Analyzing how often MLB draft picks become stars and which MLB picks produce the most stars can help you pinpoint the rookies most likely to perform later in their careers, making their early cards incredibly valuable.
Is it worth collecting rookie cards from players taken outside the top 10?
Yes, based on history. A premium rookie card doesn’t require a premium draft slot, and many high-performers like Matt Chapman or Sonny Gray were mid-round picks.
Does draft position actually predict MLB stardom?
According to most MLB draft analysis reports, it’s a fairly reliable indicator, but it is by no means a guarantee of MLB draft pick success over time. The best MLB draft picks (first picks) reach the majors at a 73% clip and outproduce every later round on average.
About the Author
